Residential Space A creative outlet during residency, turned ongoing virtual soap box

Posted on Wednesday, January 11th, 2006 at 2:28 pm. About Ramblings.

In response to James’ new country…

James recently replied to my post about eliminating states with his own about using one of them to start his own country (a Galt’s Gorge of sorts, it seems). 🙂 I tried adding a comment to his blog, but the computer here does not like MSN for some reason. So I will post my response here.

I can understand his desire to go to a consumption tax rather than a graduated federal income tax. Here are my concerns though:

– Initially, it benefits me because I am sharing the tax burden with the lower class.

– Then, I realize, being the frugal-to-a-fault person that I am, that I can get by with paying less tax if I never spend any money. I stop eating at nice restaurants because I can pay minimal tax by preparing meals at home. I do not purchase a new television because the idea of paying that much tax makes me cringe. Anything non-essential, I refuse to buy.

– Retail businesses begin hurting due to decreased sales. Eventually, if it continues, they begin laying people off. Stocks are down.

– My uncle, who owns his own building company in Austin, TX, now hurts because no one wants a new house. Other builders are in the same situation. Because he is hurting, the lumber and plumbing companies are hurting.

– The country enters a recession, stocks are down, and eventually it does hurt me, because in my efforts to save money my investment portfolio has now taken a dive.

Of course, this may be a bit melodramatic, but it is something to consider. People in Europe pay high consumption taxes and it doesn’t necessarily stop them from spending, but then again they are funding healthcare and education through the government, and I know James is not in favor of bigger government controlling these sorts of things.

You may say – yes, but most people are not that frugal and will continue to spend money. I would agree, but then I think the idea of paying tax results in a psychological aversion to spending. Look at the “tax-free” days just prior to the new school year starting each year. In Charleston, SC, sales tax is 6.0%. The stores are FLOODED with people during the tax-free weekend. I mean, they are flooded to the point of chaos at times. Now, if I were to run a tv ad stating: “Everything is SIX PERCENT OFF for ONE DAY ONLY!!!” people would say, “Yeah, right. It’s not worth it.” But I would argue that because they are not having to pay TAX on items, something compels them to spend money. So I do believe consumption taxes on every day items, other than those that are expected to be heavily taxed, will lead to less spending.

I like the happy medium the state of Washington has attempted to create. We have no state income tax (a beautiful thing, I must admit!), and there is no sales tax on essentials, such as groceries. Items that are very heavily taxed, though, include tobacco, alcohol, gasoline, property, and vehicle registrations. Heavy taxation provides the extra incentive away from driving cars when public transportation is available too, so it helps to keep the city clean! 😀

Finally, though – the biggest reason I have difficulty getting behind eliminating the federal income tax in favor of a consumption tax is because Jim DeMint, R-SC is strongly in favor of it. Since he heavily supports the consumption-only tax, and he’s just a huge douche-bag, I cannot help but see red flags.

2 responses to 'In response to James’ new country…'.

Comments and pings are currently closed for 'In response to James’ new country…'.

Fatal error: Uncaught Error: Call to undefined function ereg() in /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ Stack trace: #0 /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ require() #1 /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ comments_template() #2 /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ include('/homepages/33/d...') #3 /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ require_once('/homepages/33/d...') #4 /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ require('/homepages/33/d...') #5 {main} thrown in /homepages/33/d94449870/htdocs/blogs/ on line 41